This is a question that gets asked fairly regularly.

The first part of this article is from one of the posters (Tim) from my forum.
The second part is from me (also from the forum)


This is Tim
I personally think the time a piece takes you to learn depends on what style of guitar you start with or prefer. I only started playing guitar a few months ago from an excellent instructional dvd that covered acoustic fingerstles because i like folk music and especially fingerpicked music. i learnt several picking patterns within a couple of days and my speed was good within a week because i learnt to use the correct fingers straight from the start and practised for 3-8 hours a day depending on whether i was at work or not to really make progress quickly. When Mike put up the classical gas pieces i was fine and have learnt the 4 parts pretty easily (about a day for each part except part 4 which took about 30 mins beacuse we could all see where it was going in part 3!) because i didn't have to spend anytime working out where my fingers go and which strings they will pluck it was just a case of chord shapes and tempo.

But my strumming is a different matter! i had pretty much only learnt chords that were used in the fingersyle dvd and really only knew A,E,C, AND D well. The last month and a half i have mostly been practising changing between chords and strumming patterns and i have found this quite challenging, even a simple sounding piece like the times they are a changin proved initially challenging because i had mostly neglected strumming, changing chords and practising with picks. i couldnt hit the bass note of the c chord without catching the 6th string so the tune sounded terrible. Thankfully i can play it pretty well now but it took me a week's hard practice to be able to play it well! I think in the future fingerpicking is going to be 'my thing' and i will use strummed pieces to broaden my style of playing. my friend at work started a month before me and his strumming is really really good but he can't pick to save his life he could learn times... in a few mins but it would probably take him a long while to learn classical gas part 2 or 3.

keep at it, correct and precise practice is the only way, oh and visualise the chord shape you are about to go into this has helped me a lot, see it in your mind and your fingers will start to get there quicker and more accurately!        

__________________
Tim

And this is Mike
Hi...

I reckon I'm a fairly 'natural' guitarist so I'll give you an idea how long it takes me to learn a new piece.

Obviously it depends on the difficulty of the piece but....out of the starting blocks for a moderately difficult piece, I will practice for say three to four hours a day and I reckon 5 or 6 days to get the piece right.

There are some pieces that have taken me three months to learn and some that I don't suppose I'll ever know perfectly.

In all of this you have to remember that it is the journey not the destination that gives satisfaction. In all these years of going through the "I must learn that!" to the "Well I can play it now so what next" I still forget that I will want to move on to the next piece as soon as the last one is learned.

Your audience have no idea how long it takes which is why they say....oh I'd love to play the guitar......

If only they knew.
Mike

So what do YOU think?
How often and for long do you practice?
How long does it normally take you to learn a new piece?